Florida Gulf Coast League: Ramping Up for 2021 with Roster News (Including Returners & New Players)
January 12, 2021
The Manatee Squeeze team will be one of 10 in the 2021 Florida Gulf Coast League.
After a successful first year of playing softball last summer in the Sunshine State—when much of the fastpitch world was shut down due to COVID-19—the Florida Gulf Coast League (FGCL) is getting ready for the 2021 season with 10 teams getting ready for action.
Click HEREto see why the FGCL was one of our Top 15 Stories of 2020!
There will be 10 teams this year and on Monday the league announced the 125 players who are as of now expected to compete this summer.
Said one FGCL official: “There is definitely some serious talent coming this way!”
Here’s a look at the team rosters including coaches, returning players and new additions as they stand at this point…
*****
2020 Champs Myakka City River Mocs
Michaela Transue returning as head coach.
Seven returners including league MVP Mack Leonard (Ill St), Gabby Benson (GA St), Madi Davis (UCF), Kaylee Erickson (BYU), Claire Ginder (Furman), Ari Quinones (UW) and Lizzie Shubert (Stetson).
Newcomers include Madison Harris (UVA) and Casey Goguts (GA Tech), along with Grayson Radcliffe (Indiana), Jazzy Contreras (Oregon), Saxon Radcliffe (ETSU), Paige Rauch (Villanova).
Manatee Squeeze
Head coach, Kara Dill (Texas A&M).
Returners include Kenna Wilkey (Northwestern), Megan Ricks (FGCU), Taylor Johnson (Wisconsin), Nikki Cuchran (Northwestern),
Newcomers are Carsyn Saabye (FSU), Erin McDonald (Wichita St), Lauren Shaw (Iowa), Madison Owens (South Carolina), Maddie Bejarano (UCF), Molly Rainey (UCF), Jordan Moore (Samford), Maddie Gallagher (South Carolina), Cam Cecil (Long Beach St)
Newcomers are Jessi Puk (Ole Miss), Taylor Herschbach (Valparaiso), Camille Corona (Texas), Grace Jewell (UCF), Kendal Cook (Missouri)
Pioneers
Erica Beach returning as head coach with Karlie Milburn (Michigan GA) assisting.
Returners include: Kara Saylor (Stetson), Kayla Howald (Campbell), Sophie Hannabas (Southeastern LA), Cammeo Presutti (FAU), Jordyn Petty (Barry), Taylor Gilmore (Colorado St),
Newcomers: Kailey Christian (Delaware), Tyler Trott (Colorado St), Jada Smallwood (Maryland), Hanna Garber (Delaware), McKayla Timmons (Ball St), Abi Annett (North Florida), Paige Pfent (North Florida), Carsten Puckett (Clemson), Kaitlyn Tucker (Presbyterian)
Siesta Key Phinz
Head Coach Aaron Vail (Furman).
Players include: Maia Radar (Oregon St), Erin Brown (St. Johns), Jaeda McFarland (Maryland), Emma Whitfield (Clemson), Mazie MacFarlane (Utah St), Mackenzie MacFarlane (Utah St), Mia Kraimer (South Dakota), Abi Stuart (Clemson), Lexie Webb (Fresno St), Rachael Hathoot (New Mexico), Izzy Owen (New Mexico), Alyssa Pinto (San Diego St), Kinley Stewart (GA Tech), Blake Neleman (GA Tech), Kaitlyn Orme (Ferris St), Kat Rodriguez (Quinnipiac), Catie Dobbs (Syracuse)
Sarasota Circus
Head Coach Carsyn Gordan (PBA GA), Assistant Coach Aleima Lopez (Ole Miss GA).
Players include: Stormy Kotzelnick (UW), Jordyn Wolfe (Louisville), Jocelyn Alonso (FIU), Natalie Morgan (Furman), Riley Grunberg (UTSA), Taylor Medina (USTA), Kasey Fava (UCF), Ellie Armistead (Georgia), Kayla McGory (UNF), Jenna Greene (Presbyterian), Megan Schumacher (Missouri), Riley Frizell (Missouri)
South Bradenton Skeeters
Head Coach Cara Parker (Santa Fe), Assistant Coach Marisa Runyon (TTU).
Players: Melina Livingston (Penn St), Emily Winburn (Delaware), Lauren Klein (Stetson), Bailey Turnbow (ETSU), Morgan Britt (UNCW), Chloe Lee (Marshall), Aly Harrel (Marshall), Jamaica Flowers (AL State), Sterling Hairston (Campbell), Rachel Warrens (George Mason), Cally Kildow (Arkansas), Raegan Conley (FAU), Kayleigh Roper (Michigan St), Morgan Shannon (St. Leo), Alex Storako (Michigan)
Anna Maria Aquanauts
Head Coach Ellie Cooper (FSU/New Zealand WNT), Assistant Coach Courtney Gettins (Alabama/Vol Asst Texas).
Players Kinsey Goelz (Florida), Bailee Richardson (Ga St), Bailey Grossenbacher ((FIU), Wylie Glover (Wichita St), Daisy Hess (GA St), Mallorie Black (GA Tech), Zoie Smith (Bucknell), Kayla Jensen (Quinnipiac), Zoie Smith (Bucknell), Kat Grill (Alabama), Avery Goelz (Florida)
Extra Elite 100 Rankings: Class of 2028: Dynamite Athletes #20-11
As the Class of 2028 Extra Elite 100 rankings move closer to the top, the spotlight now shines on the athletes ranked #20–11 — players...
Bonnie Holland
EXTRA ELITE 100 INFLUENCERS, NEWS
Ariel Yee’s Journey: Mastering the Craft
Extra Elite 100 Influencer: Ariel Yee Ariel Yee October 25, 2025 Extra Inning Softball spotlights the impressive rise of Class of 2027 catcher Ariel Yee,...
Jayden Mount
NEWS, PLAYER RANKINGS NEWS
Extra Elite 100 Rankings: Class of 2028 Stars Ranked #30-21
As the Class of 2028 Extra Elite 100 rankings unfold, one thing is certain—this class has made history. With more than 1,200 players nominated, it...
Bonnie Holland
NEWS, SPORTS PERFORMANCE
Core Training and What It Is (and Isn’t)
Core Training and What It Is (and Isn’t) Alex Webb October 20, 2025 | 6:00PM ET Everyone wants abs, and everyone loves to train them....
Jayden Mount
NEWS, OVERCOMING ADVERSITY
ACL to All-In: Emily Valdez’s Road Back
How Emily Valdez Overcame an ACL Tear Jayden Mount October 20, 2025 For most athletes, the toughest battles aren’t fought on the field—they’re fought in...
Jayden Mount
NEWS, VOICES FROM THE FIELD INTERVIEWS
Voices From the Field: La’Breah Sands
Voices From the Field Jayden Mount October 18, 2025 | 6AM EST For La’Breah Sands, softball is far more than a sport—it’s a reflection of...