Madness Monday: Is The Orange Safety Bag Protecting Players—or The Game?

Madness Monday: Is The Orange Safety Bag Protecting Players—or The Game?
Jayla making a fantastic catch at first base for the Georgia Impact – Caymol.

Madness Monday

Jayden Mount
October 20, 2025 | 10:00AM ET

Extra Inning Softball
Your source for rankings
Download our EIS App HERE

Welcome to Madness Monday, our digital deep dive where we skip the softballs and go straight for the big questions dividing the fastpitch world. From dugout debates to social media threads, these are the conversations that get people talking—and we’re bringing them to you every week.

This week’s question: The NCAA’s new rule adds an orange safety bag at first base to reduce collisions — but is it protecting players or overprotecting the game?

Join Now!

EXTRA INNING SOFTBALL

The results are in from our Dugout Discussion Polls:

  1. Love it — safety should always come first, even if it helps just one player avoid injury: 84.75%
  2. Why do we always try to weaken the game? First obstruction, now this — let athletes play!: 3.39%
  3. Mixed feelings — it’s safer, but it changes how the game looks and feels: 1.69%
  4. It’s fine for youth or rec ball, but unnecessary at the college level: 6.78%
  5. Grateful for safety — but wish rule changes were more consistent across all levels: 3.39%

The overwhelming majority of voters are all-in on safety, agreeing that even one injury prevented makes the change worth it. But the rest of the softball world isn’t so sure—some say it alters the traditional look and feel of the game, while others argue it should only apply to youth levels where collisions are more frequent.

Join Jayden Mount and Laina Holmgren as they break down both sides—debating whether this orange addition is a necessary step toward player protection or an overcorrection that chips away at the sport’s competitive edge.

This is where the madness starts.

📲 Tag us on Twitter and on Facebook
📸 Follow us on Instagram
🎥 Subscribe to our YouTube channel
🎙️ Listen to our Extra Inning Softball: Voices from the Field Podcast 

TRENDING NEWS

TRENDING NEWS DESCRIPTION
ALL NEWSStay updated with the latest updates.
CLUB NEWSClub News: 14-18U
COMMITTEDCommitted News!
DRILL ZONEOver 100 Drills
FIVE-STARSNew 5-Star Rating System
AMBASSADORSEIS Impact Ambassadors
INFIELDERSNew changes to ranking Infielders
PARENT HUBInsights from softball parents!
POLLSVote and share your take on trending topics.
EIS MOBILE APPDownload our new EIS App!
RANKINGSRankings Interview
RANKINGS LISTSRankings Lists!
RANKINGS NEWSRankings News!
RECRUITINGNavigating the softball recruiting process.
STOREYour go-to for stylish gear.
TEAM RANKINGSTeam rankings return to EIS!
TOURNAMENTSTournaments Matter in Rankings
UNCOMMITTEDUncommitted News!
YOUTH NEWSYouth News! 10-12U

Join Now!

COPYRIGHT © 2025 Extra Inning Softball TM

BREAKING NEWS: Extra Inning Softball Launches New Mobile App — Now Available in the App Store

National Signing Day Contest: Your Chance to Star in Extra Inning Softball’s Miniseries!

More
articles

Search

Transfer Tracker Updates

Fill out this form to submit your transfer updates. These changes are subject to approval.

Oops! We could not locate your form.

Interested in an Extra Elite 100 shirt?

Fill out the form below to verify that you’re part of the Extra Elite!

Oops! We could not locate your form.