Why I’m Speaking Out: Parents, It’s Time to Question Your Coaches

Why I'm Speaking Out: Parents, It's Time to Question Your Coaches

A Message to Travel Ball Coaches, Organization Leaders, and Parents

Who Decides if an Athlete Deserves to Be Ranked? As CEO of Extra Inning Softball, I want to address a growing concern that I believe deserves the attention of our entire fastpitch softball community.

Recently, I’ve had conversations and received emails from travel ball coaches and organization leaders who only want certain athletes within their programs nominated for rankings.

In some cases, their reasoning is that they only want athletes nominated if they believe those players have a realistic chance of earning a Top 100 national ranking.

In other situations, I’ve been asked not to rank athletes whose parents submitted nominations without receiving approval from their travel ball organization.

I respect the work these coaches and organization leaders do. I understand they have their own expectations and policies.

But I strongly disagree with the idea that only athletes considered Top 100 prospects should be nominated for rankings.

That thinking reflects a fundamental misunderstanding of our rankings program, and more importantly, it can limit opportunities for athletes who deserve to be recognized.

Let me explain why.

Parents, It’s Time to Have the Conversation

I’m writing this article because I want parents to have meaningful conversations with their travel ball coaches and organization leaders about who is being nominated for rankings, who is making those decisions, and why.

Through my conversations with families and coaches, I’ve noticed a concerning disconnect in communication. Parents may assume their daughters are being supported in pursuing every available recruiting opportunity, while their organizations may have policies that restrict who can be nominated.

Parents deserve to know whether their organization is advocating for every college-bound athlete or selectively supporting only certain players.

Here are three questions I strongly encourage parents to ask:

These are fair questions, and I believe coaches and organization leaders should be willing to answer them.

I also want to make my position clear.

If your daughter wants to play in college and her travel ball organization does not support her being independently evaluated and ranked, I would seriously encourage you to consider whether that organization is the right fit for her future.

A travel ball program should be helping athletes pursue their collegiate goals, not limiting their opportunities based on someone else’s prediction of where they might rank.

Rankings Extend Beyond Top 100

One of the biggest misconceptions about softball rankings is that they are only intended for elite Division I prospects.

That is simply not true.

College softball offers opportunities across Division I, Division II, Division III, NAIA, and junior college programs. An athlete pursuing Division III softball deserves the opportunity to be evaluated just as much as an athlete hoping to compete at a Power 4 university.

Every officially nominated athlete is guaranteed a Regional Ranking and is considered for National Rankings and Hitter Rankings.

This is an important distinction.

Our Regional Rankings recognize athletes across a broad range of abilities and collegiate recruiting levels. National and Hitter Rankings provide additional recognition based on the Rankings Committee’s evaluation.

Not every athlete will make the National Top 100, and that’s not the expectation.

The purpose of our program is to recognize athletes based on their performance, development, and potential—not simply to identify the nation’s most elite prospects.

When coaches limit nominations to athletes they believe will make the Top 100, they misunderstand the opportunities our rankings program provides.

And more importantly, they may be preventing deserving athletes from receiving recognition that could support their recruiting journeys.

Coaches Have a Voice

I have tremendous respect for travel ball coaches and organization leaders. Their insight is valuable, and we have intentionally built coach involvement into our nomination process.

Every time an athlete is nominated, her travel ball coach receives an email notification.

Additionally, when we receive two or more nominations from the same team, we reach out directly to the coach to request feedback and additional insight.

This gives coaches an opportunity to share their observations, recommendations, and concerns with our Rankings Committee.

However, there is a difference between providing professional insight and determining whether an athlete is allowed to be evaluated.

Our nomination process permits parents, coaches, and organization leaders to submit nominations. We encourage parents to communicate with their coaches before submitting, and only one nomination is needed per athlete.

But coach approval is not required.

Just today, I was asked to remove an athlete’s nomination because her parent submitted it without permission from the organization.

I respectfully declined.

Our commitment is to honor eligible nominations and independently evaluate the athletes who have been submitted.

Through our SERV™ Methodology—Software, Evaluate, Research, and Verify—our Rankings Committee reviews travel ball statistics, tournament performance, strength of competition, athletic measurables, video, and verified accomplishments.

Coach recommendations are considered, including when a coach does not recommend an athlete. But the final rankings decisions belong to our committee.

Coaches provide the insight. Our Rankings Committee makes the evaluations.

Are Egos Getting in the Way?

I believe this is a question worth asking.

When a coach or organization leader only wants athletes nominated if they’re expected to make the National Top 100, what message does that send to everyone else on the roster?

Are we prioritizing the athlete’s recruiting opportunities, or are we concerned about how a lower ranking might reflect on the organization?

I certainly hope it’s the former.

But I believe the softball community needs to be willing to have this conversation.

An athlete’s opportunity for recognition should never be sacrificed to protect a coach’s ego or an organization’s reputation.

A player ranked regionally may be an excellent prospect for a Division II, Division III, NAIA, or junior college program.

That recognition has value, even if the athlete never appears on a National Top 100 list.

Rankings do not guarantee scholarships or recruiting offers. However, they provide another opportunity for athletes to showcase their accomplishments and increase their visibility.

Why would we want to limit that?

My Message to Parents and Coaches

To parents, I strongly encourage you to communicate with your coaches and organization leaders. Don’t assume you understand their nomination policies. Ask questions and make sure your daughter’s recruiting goals are being supported.

If your organization has concerns about your daughter being nominated, ask for an explanation. You deserve to understand the reasoning behind decisions that may affect her opportunities.

To coaches and organization leaders, I ask you to consider the bigger picture.

Your athletes have different abilities, developmental timelines, and collegiate goals. Some may become Division I prospects. Others may find the perfect fit at Division II, Division III, NAIA, or JUCO programs.

Every one of those paths matters.

Supporting an athlete’s opportunity to be evaluated does not mean guaranteeing her a particular ranking. It means allowing an independent committee to assess her accomplishments and determine her placement.

And if an organization is unwilling to support that opportunity, I believe families should seriously evaluate whether that program aligns with their daughter’s future.

My Commitment to the Softball Community

As CEO of Extra Inning Softball, I stand firmly behind our rankings process and the commitment we’ve made to athletes and families.

Our goal is not to create conflict between parents and coaches. It’s to encourage communication, transparency, and opportunities for athletes at every level.

Every college-bound athlete should be ranked.

Every nominated athlete is guaranteed a Regional Ranking and considered for National and Hitter Rankings.

An athlete does not need to be projected as a Top 100 prospect to deserve an independent evaluation.

And no coach or organization should discourage that opportunity simply because they don’t believe she will earn national recognition.

Let’s stop deciding which athletes deserve to be seen before they’ve even had the opportunity to be evaluated.

By Bonnie Holland | CEO, Extra Inning Softball

WHAT’S NEXT?

📝Class of 2032 nominations close December 14, 2026.

👉 Nominate HERE

TRENDING NEWS DESCRIPTION
ALL NEWSAll News
GET NOTIFIEDGet Notified
MyEIS360 ProfilesMyEIS360 Profiles
TOURNEY LEADERBOARDTournament Rankings
RANKINGS LEADERBOARDRankings Leaderboard
RANKINGS NEWSRankings News
SERV METHODOLOGYServ Methodology

COPYRIGHT © 2026 Extra Inning Softball™

More
articles

Search

Transfer Tracker Updates

Fill out this form to submit your transfer updates. These changes are subject to approval.

Oops! We could not locate your form.

Interested in an Extra Elite 100 shirt?

Fill out the form below to verify that you’re part of the Extra Elite!

Oops! We could not locate your form.