Should 14U+ Adopt a Game-Changing Watch List?

Should 14U+ Adopt a Game-Changing Watch List?

The conversation around how best to recognize softball athletes continues to evolve, and Extra Inning Softball recently conducted a poll asking an important question: Should we transition to a “Watch List” format for players 14U and older instead of traditional rankings? The results are in, and they reflect a range of perspectives from the softball community.

Poll Results: What the Community Thinks

“I personally like the idea of a watch list. I think, as travel ball coaches, leaders, and advocates, we should use the same language that will be used for these PSAs throughout the rest of their careers. Most national awards start with a watch list or pre-season list, and since we don’t really have an off-season, I think a watch list is the best verbiage to use.”

Here’s how voters responded:

• Yes, switch to a Watch List format. It’s less stressful for players and still highlights their achievements (54.91%)
  The majority of respondents expressed support for transitioning to a Watch List format for players 14U and older. They believe this approach can reduce the pressure rankings place on players while still celebrating their accomplishments.
• No changes. Continue to rank older players (14U+) and use Watch Lists for younger athletes (10U–12U) (31.90%)
  A significant portion of voters preferred the current system, which balances traditional rankings for older players with Watch Lists for younger athletes. For these respondents, rankings provide structure and recognition for older players during critical recruiting years.
• Undecided. I see merits in both systems and would like to hear more feedback from coaches, parents, and players before forming an opinion (8.59%)
  Some voters remain undecided, acknowledging the potential benefits of both systems. They emphasize the need for further discussion and input from the community before making a decision.
• No, keep traditional rankings. Ranked lists add value and provide clear recognition (4.60%)
  A small but vocal group of voters advocated for keeping traditional rankings intact, citing their importance in providing clear recognition for standout players.

Highlighting the Pros and Cons

The debate over Watch Lists versus traditional rankings brings up several key points. Supporters of Watch Lists believe they create a more inclusive environment, where players are recognized without the added pressure of being ranked against their peers. This format also allows for a broader celebration of talent across regions and positions.

On the other hand, traditional rankings provide a clear and structured way to measure a player’s performance and achievements. For many, rankings serve as a valuable tool for recruiting and give players concrete goals to strive toward.

Both systems have their merits, and the decision ultimately depends on what serves the athletes and the softball community best.

For further insights into the evolution of player rankings and the shift towards Watch Lists, consider reading Voices from the Field: The Evolution of Rankings and visit our Podcast: Inside the Game – Rankings, Transfer Portal, and the Future of Softball

Appreciating Community Feedback

At Extra Inning Softball, we deeply value the opinions and feedback from our readers, coaches, parents, and players. Your input is vital as we navigate decisions that impact the softball community.

Polls like this are an excellent way to spark meaningful conversations about the future of the sport. If you haven’t yet shared your thoughts, we encourage you to visit our Dugout Discussions Polls. Your voice matters, and your insights help shape the content and decisions that support the softball community.

Final Thoughts

The question of transitioning to a Watch List format for 14U and older players reflects broader conversations about balancing recognition, exposure, and player well-being. While the poll results leaned in favor of adopting Watch Lists, the diversity of responses highlights the importance of considering all perspectives.

Whether through Watch Lists, traditional rankings, or a combination of both, Extra Inning Softball remains committed to celebrating the incredible talent and hard work of athletes in the fastpitch community. Thank you to everyone who participated in the poll and contributed to this important discussion.

Let us know your thoughts in future polls, and stay tuned for more updates and insights from the softball world!

*****

JOIN OUR EIS TEAM!

COPYRIGHT © 2025 Extra Inning Softball TM

Do you have a story idea? If so, let us know HERE

EIS Stands for MORE than Just Extra Inning Softball